Articles

Wimar Gone But Metro Does Not Pull Talk Show Over Tweet


10 April 2011

 

Wimar Gone But Metro Does Not Pull Talk Show Over Tweet
Elisabeth Oktofani | April 09, 2011
Wimar Witoelar is controversially no longer on the 'Talk Indonesia' show. Its future is in question. (JG Photo/Safir Makki)
Related articles
Show’s End Not Down To Tweet: Metro TV 11:56pm Apr 6, 2011
Council Mediates Rift Between Metro TV, Dipo Alam 2:07pm Mar 2, 2011
Defiant Dipo Tells Media: I Will Never Apologise 12:34am Feb 24, 2011
Lawmakers Denounce Call for Boycott of ‘Critical Media’ 2:13am Feb 23, 2011
Press Council, News Organizations Hit Back at Dipo 2:03am Feb 23, 2011
Share This Page
 1Share
Post a comment 
Please login to post comment
Comments
favenchi12:58pm Apr 9, 2011
seems Metro TV has gone into reverse gear....the programme without Wimar will not be the same.
Hasugian12:53pm Apr 9, 2011
At the end of the day, it wouldn't be overgeneralising to say that Indonesian channels are all biased. That makes it no better than sinetron-oriented TVs. Can't blame people to count on cables for enlightenment.
"More leisurely and less serious program" my foot. Without Wimar, do you honestly think you can make Politics sound like a lot of fun? You might as well be having dear old Tiffie host the program. Now that will be a first-ranked comedy!
1
Television news station Metro TV says the English-language show “Talk Indonesia” will remain on the air, after a co-host alleged it was being dropped over a critical tweet he had posted. 
The show aired on Saturday as usual  -- but without Wimar Witoelar, a former presidential spokesperson for Gus Dur who appears to have been dropped from the show without a formal announcement.
The broadcaster previously said the show, hosted by former CNN anchor Dalton Tanonaka, actress Rahayu Saraswati and formerly Wimar, would be axed as part of a revamp of the station’s weekend lineup. 
On Friday, however, Metro TV news director Tomi Suryopratomo said an evaluation had been completed and the decision had been made to keep “Talk Indonesia” on the air. 
 “This is the nature of television as a media,” Tomi said on Friday. 
“We have to evaluate our program lineup. It’s not something unusual for the media, even CNN conducts reviews of its programs.” 
Tomi had previously denied a claim by Wimar that the station was considering scrapping the show because of a Twitter message that Wimar wrote criticizing what he perceived as Metro TV’s skewed coverage of the Libya conflict. 
Wimar claimed the station misconstrued the criticism — which questioned why Metro TV’s editorial team was supportive of Muammar el-Qaddafi following the air strikes by Western forces, when previously he had been considered a “bandit” — as being targeted at station owner Surya Paloh. 
On Friday, Wimar welcomed Metro TV’s decision to retain the show. 
“I never insulted Surya Paloh in my Twitter posts. You can audit them if you want, there’s nothing in my statements that insults him,” he said. 
“There’s someone at Metro TV who doesn’t want me there, so they claimed that I insulted Suryo Paloh in my tweet. 
“Instead of making false accusations like that, they could have just told me nicely they no longer wanted me to be part of the team. I’d have no objections to that.” 
He added he had laughed when he found out “it was Surya Paloh’s request to keep airing ‘Talk Indonesia’ out of respect for the audience.” 
However, Tomi said the show was not one of the station’s more popular programs. 
“ ‘Talk Indonesia’ is one program that doesn’t generate high ratings because it’s a very segmented program,” he said. 
“However, it was the programming department’s decision to evaluate and develop the program, including choosing who would be the guests on the program.” 
“Talk Indonesia” has tackled hot news topics each week in English since being launched in November 2010. 
Tomi previously said Metro TV was aiming to present more leisurely and less serious programs on the weekends.

 

Jakarta Globe reports my words accurately but they were a bit  careless in checking MetroTV's testimony. First of all, Talkindo airs on Sunday, not Saturday. More complicated are the inconsistencies of MetroTV statements. As far as I am satisfied that my colleagues have the chance to go on with the show. Poor management ethics are not my direct concern but I deplore the disservice done to Metro owners.

 

also: in Surabaya Post

http://www.surabayapost.co.id/?mnu=berita&act=view&id=772fa75d5e279e69fc41766cfde8d9a2&jenis=d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e

 

Elisabeth Oktofani | April 09, 2011

Wimar Witoelar is controversially no longer on the 'Talk Indonesia' show. Its future is in question.

 

(JG Photo/Safir Makki)

 

Comments

favenchi12:58pm Apr 9, 2011

seems Metro TV has gone into reverse gear....the programme without Wimar will not be the same.


Hasugian12:53pm Apr 9, 2011

At the end of the day, it wouldn't be overgeneralising to say that Indonesian channels are all biased. That makes it no better than sinetron-oriented TVs. Can't blame people to count on cables for enlightenment.

"More leisurely and less serious program" my foot. Without Wimar, do you honestly think you can make Politics sound like a lot of fun? You might as well be having dear old Tiffie host the program. Now that will be a first-ranked comedy!


 

Television news station Metro TV says the English-language show “Talk Indonesia” will remain on the air, after a co-host alleged it was being dropped over a critical tweet he had posted. 

 

The show aired on Saturday as usual  -- but without Wimar Witoelar, a former presidential spokesperson for Gus Dur who appears to have been dropped from the show without a formal announcement.

 

The broadcaster previously said the show, hosted by former CNN anchor Dalton Tanonaka, actress Rahayu Saraswati and formerly Wimar, would be axed as part of a revamp of the station’s weekend lineup. 

 

On Friday, however, Metro TV news director Tomi Suryopratomo said an evaluation had been completed and the decision had been made to keep “Talk Indonesia” on the air. 

 

 “This is the nature of television as a media,” Tomi said on Friday. 

 

“We have to evaluate our program lineup. It’s not something unusual for the media, even CNN conducts reviews of its programs.” 

 

Tomi had previously denied a claim by Wimar that the station was considering scrapping the show because of a Twitter message that Wimar wrote criticizing what he perceived as Metro TV’s skewed coverage of the Libya conflict. 

 

Wimar claimed the station misconstrued the criticism — which questioned why Metro TV’s editorial team was supportive of Muammar el-Qaddafi following the air strikes by Western forces, when previously he had been considered a “bandit” — as being targeted at station owner Surya Paloh. 

 

On Friday, Wimar welcomed Metro TV’s decision to retain the show. 

 

“I never insulted Surya Paloh in my Twitter posts. You can audit them if you want, there’s nothing in my statements that insults him,” he said. 

 

“There’s someone at Metro TV who doesn’t want me there, so they claimed that I insulted Suryo Paloh in my tweet. 

 

“Instead of making false accusations like that, they could have just told me nicely they no longer wanted me to be part of the team. I’d have no objections to that.” 

 

He added he had laughed when he found out “it was Surya Paloh’s request to keep airing ‘Talk Indonesia’ out of respect for the audience.” 

 

However, Tomi said the show was not one of the station’s more popular programs. 

 

“ ‘Talk Indonesia’ is one program that doesn’t generate high ratings because it’s a very segmented program,” he said. 

 

“However, it was the programming department’s decision to evaluate and develop the program, including choosing who would be the guests on the program.” 

 

“Talk Indonesia” has tackled hot news topics each week in English since being launched in November 2010. 

 

Tomi previously said Metro TV was aiming to present more leisurely and less serious programs on the weekends.

 

 

 

Print article only

7 Comments:

  1. From sen on 10 April 2011 20:21:31 WIB
    I am a fan of Talk Indonesia. Always watch the show before going to play badminton on Sunday morning.

    This morning it is not as good as usual. There are of course some funny moments like always but pretty boring without Wimar.

    I hardly watch Metro TV news at all. Even though I can understand Indonesian and English, I prefer to watch channels like CNBC or Bloomberg than other channels. I don\'t like to watch CNN or Fox news as well.

    So very sad that the only show I always watch in Metro TV is no longer worth watching

  2. From KRMT Jangkrik Sukro on 11 April 2011 13:39:48 WIB
    who's wimar?
  3. From Albertus on 12 April 2011 19:54:46 WIB
    Saya juga merasa aneh, pemberitaan Metro mengenai konflik ini tendensiusnya benar-benar parah, memakan mentah-mentah propaganda Gaddafi, membelokkan dengan mudah kenyataan lapangan.

    Biasanya pemberitaan biasnya dibuat halus, kalau yang ini biasnya nyata sekali. Terlihat jelas ada campur tangan dibaliknya.
  4. From Svahmi on 17 April 2011 11:05:44 WIB
    yeah; I realized that Talkindo has segmented on air topic; but as i ever said in my Twitter that my reason for buyin LCD is for watching talkindo, the collaboration between rahayu and wimar was so excited me so much; on the way they perpetuated current issues was different with any other news program; hahahh; two NEws channel mogul in this country are really vested their interest on it.
  5. From Rangga Aditya on 17 April 2011 14:29:18 WIB
    now i know why ... O well ... One show down, another will come right? :D
  6. From Ida on 12 May 2011 09:58:54 WIB
    Everything in indonesia become unpredictable
  7. From Adit Putra on 20 May 2011 21:05:56 WIB
    Knowledge to Elevate "policital agenda".

Add Your Comment

Comments with fake names or email may be rejected.

Real Name:

Real Email: (will not be shown)

Message: (stay on topic)

Sorry, No HTML

Important! Please type Security Image here:

« Home